The short answer
If your agency can show you, on one page, where last month's enquiries came from and what each one cost, it's working or it's fixable. If nobody can show you that, you're not paying for marketing. You're paying for activity.
You pay the invoice every month. For the owners who come to me it sits somewhere between £500 and £1,000, and when I ask what came in from it last month, the honest answer is usually a pause and then "it's hard to say".
It isn't hard to say. It's just never been said. So here are the five questions I'd put to any agency, including my own. I run one, Action Marketing, so this isn't a case against agencies. It's the test a good one passes in ten minutes and a poor one can't pass at all.
Where did last month's enquiries come from?
Not impressions. Not reach. Enquiries, by source: Google search, Google ads, social, referrals, the website form, the phone. If the answer is a list of sources with a number next to each, you're fine. If the answer is a screenshot of a graph going up, ask again.
An agency that's working knows this number because it's the number they manage by. One that doesn't know it isn't managing anything. It's posting.
What did each enquiry cost?
Take what you spent on a channel and divide it by the enquiries that channel produced. That's it. It's the only figure that lets you compare one thing against another, and it's the one that goes missing most often, because it's the one that can look bad.
If your agency has never shown you a cost per enquiry, they're probably not hiding it. More often, they've never worked it out either.
What did you switch off last month, and why?
This is the one that catches people out. A working agency stops things. Campaigns that didn't convert, keywords that brought the wrong people, a platform that never earned its fee. If nothing has been switched off in six months, nobody has been looking closely enough to notice what isn't working.
What would you do with another £500?
An agency that's on top of your account has a next move with a number attached: "I'd put it into the search campaign, because that's bringing enquiries at half the cost of social." An agency that's guessing says "more of the same", or asks what you'd like.
You're not actually offering the money. You're finding out whether anyone has a plan.
Can I see the accounts?
The ad accounts. The analytics. The pixel. In your name, with your login, and the agency added as a user. If any of that sits in the agency's name, you don't own your own marketing. You're renting it, and the day you leave, the history leaves with you.
Ask for it to be moved. A good agency will do it that week. The reaction tells you most of what you need to know.
What a good answer looks like
One page. Enquiries by source with a cost next to each. One thing stopped. One thing starting, with the number it's meant to move. The accounts in your name. That's the whole report, and it takes less time to read than this post.
If you get that page, keep the agency. Even if the numbers are poor, you've got an agency that can see, and seeing is what you were paying for.
If the answers aren't there
Don't sack anyone on the spot. Ask for the page by the next invoice. If it arrives, good. If it doesn't, you've found your leak, and you can decide what to do about it with a clear head rather than an angry one.
This is the first half of what I do in the 90-Day Marketing & AI Plan: the leak list and the evidence sheet are these five questions, written down with your numbers in them. The second half is what to do next. Either way, you'll leave able to say what your marketing is doing, which is more than most owners can.